The Western Region has some of the best resources for on shore wind generation in Europe, and in the future, as technology improves, for offshore renewable energy. The draft National Energy and Climate Plan (NECP) submitted to the EU and published yesterday (19.12.18) made a number of commitments for 2030 in relation to electricity generation and use, including the following:
- Renewables in our power system will rise from 30% to at least 55% with a broader range of technologies likely to be deployed, e.g. offshore wind, solar, biomass
- Coal and peat will be removed from electricity generation which will almost halve the emissions from the electricity sector.
- Penetration of electric vehicles into our transport fleet will build to around 20%.
These will all have a significant impact on how we will generate and use electricity. It is therefore useful to understand the current pattern of generation and demand in the Region before considering options for the future.
The Western Development Commission (WDC) has recently conducted a review of electricity transmission infrastructure in the Western Region. It examined current and future needs for transmission infrastructure in the Region, and considered how increased renewable electricity generation, along with new ways of using and managing electricity and new methods of improving the use of existing transmission infrastructure might impact on need for investment. We have published a summary of its findings in WDCInsights Electricity Transmission for Renewable Generation- What’s needed in the Western Region?
In this post the focus is on current and future renewable generation connections in the Region. Next year, when we have had the opportunity to review the draft NECP and consider the “all-of-Government” Climate Action Plan to be completed in early 2019, it will be clearer what renewable generation connections will be required further into the future, and from that, what further transmission investment will be important.
Electricity Generation in the Western Region
The Western Region already has a significant connected renewable generation; almost half of the generation in the Region is renewable (Figure 1). There is 1,371MW of conventional generation. This capacity is mainly across Moneypoint coal fired power station in West Co. Clare (863MW), Tynagh gas fired power station in East Co. Galway (404MW) and Tawnaghmore oil fired peaking plant in North Co. Mayo (104MW). In 2017 these power stations generated 4,390 GWh, which was approximately 15% of the national demand in 2017.
Figure 1: Generation in the Western Region
There is 165MW of hydro generation in the WDC region. This capacity is mainly at Ardnacrusha hydro station in Co. Clare (86MW) and the Erne stations (65MW) in Co. Donegal. On shore wind generation makes up the rest of the renewable electricity generation in the Region (the locations are discussed further below).
In the future with the ending of coal fired generation as committed to in the draft National Energy and Climate Plan, the vast majority of renewable electricity generation in the Western Region will come from onshore wind and other developing sources including solar and potentially offshore wind and marine generation.
Demand and Generation connections in the Western Region
There is substantially higher capacity of both renewable and conventional generation compared to demand in the region. Renewable generation currently connected (1,343MW) produces approximately 3,750GWh of renewable electricity. Considering total peak demand of 651MW and assuming the nation-wide demand capacity factor of 65%, the total demand in region is approximately 3,700GWh. It can be concluded that on an annual basis the Western Region is currently producing enough renewable generation to meet 100% of its own demand. By 2020 the Region will definitely be a net provider of renewable electricity to the rest of Ireland making a significant contribution to the 2020 RES-E targets.
Figure 2 shows the levels of connected renewable generation in the region (1,343MW) and conventional generation (1,371MW) as discussed above. Maximum demand (at peak) was estimated by MullanGrid as 651 MW with minimum demand 164MW.
Figure 2: Current Generation and Demand in the Western Region
By 2020 there could be approximately 1,760MW of renewable generation connected in the WDC region, 1,595MW of wind generation and 165MW of hydro generation. There is a further 1,000MW of renewable generation in the WDC region that will have contracted or been offered connections by mid-2019 (as shown in Figure 2 above) and there is 173MW of further potential on shore wind connections in the short term (as allocated under the Enduring Connection Policy Phase 1 (ECP-1)). Clearly the potential for renewable generation and the opportunities the Region provides are significant.
Generation and Demand at County level
It is interesting to look briefly at the patterns of generation and demand at county level in the Western Region (Figure 3). Donegal, which has the third largest connected capacity of on shore wind generation in Ireland, is clearly significant force in the Region’s transition to renewable electricity.
It currently has 480 MW of connected renewable generation with significant hydro generation (75MW) and 405MW capacity of wind generation with a further 254MW of contracted generation. Galway and Clare and the next most important counties for renewable generation, with Ardnacrusha making a significant contribution (86MW) in Clare, while most of Galway’s renewable generation (286MW) from wind. These counties have high levels of contracted wind generation which will be connected in the short term. Mayo currently has 83MW of connected wind capacity but has 406MW of contracted generation to be connected.
Figure 3: Generation and Demand in Western Region counties
In all Western Region counties currently connected renewable generation is well above the average county demand. Table 1 below gives the detail of the connected, contracted and ECP-1 capacity in each county in the Western Region alongside the estimated demand in each county (although Sligo and Leitrim are considered together).
Table 1: Connected, Contracted and future renewable generation and Demand in Western Region counties.
The transmission system has been essential in enabling the Western Region to achieve these relatively high levels of renewable generation. There has been substantial investment in the transmission network in the Region the majority of which, recently, has been in upgrading the existing electricity transmission network to provide additional capacity. However, to allow for the continued growth of renewable generation in the Region, further investment in new transmission infrastructure is required.
There is capacity in the current transmission system for more renewable generation in areas of the Western Region including large parts of Co. Roscommon, Co. Clare and Co. Galway. However there is concern about the pace and scale of development of new transmission circuits elsewhere in the Region. The areas of particular concern in the medium term are Co. Donegal and North Mayo. In Donegal, by 2022, it is expected that the connected renewable generation will have exceeded the capacity of the existing transmission system. While the planned North Connacht project will provide critical infrastructure for currently connected and some of the planned renewable generation in development in North Mayo/West Sligo, it will not provide ffor further renewable generation in the area. In the medium to long term there could also be a need for new transmission circuits to Co. Sligo/Co. Leitrim. Considering the extended timelines (at least 10 years) to deliver new transmission infrastructure it is essential to take a long-term view of the generation needs and potential in these areas.
It is important that there is a three-pronged approach to developing the transmission grid in the Region:
- Upgrading existing transmission infrastructure;
- New transmission infrastructure;
- Implementing smart grid solutions.
Although new transmission infrastructure is the most challenging to deliver it is critical for the development of more renewable generation in the Region. Other factors that will impact on growth of renewable generation are the planning process and the public acceptance of onshore wind generation. Recent new transmission projects have faced strong local opposition and a lack of local political support.
To achieve long term ambitious climate action increased renewable electricity generation will be essential. Therefore further investment in transmission grid with sufficient capacity for new generation connections is crucial.
 The Electricity Transmission Infrastructure Review for the Western Development Commission was conducted by MullanGrid Consulting.
 This is a simple average of minimum and maximum demand.
 EirGrid and ESB Networks, regulated by the Commission for the Regulation of Utilities (CRU), invest in and develop the electricity grid.